New York moves to ban chatbots from giving legal advice

NY Bill SB 7263 passed the Internet & Technology Committee last week. The bill would prohibit AI tools from providing legal advice to consumers.

Key points:

  • New York Senate Bill S7263 would prohibit AI chatbots from providing legal or medical advice and bar them from impersonating licensed professionals such as doctors and lawyers.
  • The bill advanced out of the Internet and Technology Committee on a 6–0 vote and includes a private right of action, allowing users to sue chatbot owners for damages and attorney's fees.
  • Chatbot owners would also be required to display clear, conspicuous notice that users are interacting with an AI system — though that disclosure would not limit their liability.

A bill under consideration by the New York state legislature would prohibit AI-powered chatbots from providing legal or medical advice and allow users to bring civil lawsuits against chatbot owners who violate the ban. Senate Bill S7263, introduced last session, advanced out of the Internet and Technology Committee last Wednesday on a 6–0 vote, as part of a broader package of AI chatbot regulation measures.

The bill targets chatbots that impersonate licensed professionals and bars them from providing "substantive response, information, or advice" that would constitute the unauthorised practice of law or violate professional licensing rules. Chatbot owners would additionally be required to provide "clear, conspicuous, and explicit" notice — displayed in the same language as the chatbot and in a readable font size — informing users that they are interacting with a non-human system. Critically, however, the bill clarifies that providing this disclosure does not absolve owners of liability.

The bill's private right of action is among its most significant provisions. Under that mechanism, users who experience violations could recover damages and attorney's fees through civil litigation. Experts have long argued that AI and data-governance laws carry less force without such enforcement tools. Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey, for example, has written that private rights of action provide a "significant deterrent effect." If signed by the governor, the law would take effect 90 days later.

S7263 is one of several bills in a wider legislative package steered by state Sen. Kristen Gonzalez, who also chairs the technology committee. Other measures in the package address protections for minors from unsafe chatbot features, new rules for biometric data and synthetic content, and privacy regulations targeting platforms such as the gaming platform Roblox. Gonzalez framed the package as a safeguard against AI innovation advancing "at the expense of New Yorkers' safety, especially our kids" — remarks that followed January settlements between Character.AI and Google over lawsuits linking their chatbots to the deaths of several minors.

Customer Stories

See how leading enterprise in-house teams have scaled smarter with Legal.io's high-caliber flex talent.

More from Legal.io


August 6, 2021 Report: Legal Jobs See a Huge Recovery in Jobs Lost During Pandemic
August 6, 2021 Report: Legal Jobs See a Huge Recovery in Jobs Lost During Pandemic

The latest Bureau of Labor Statistics jobs report showed roughly one million jobs were added in July.

Aug 13, 2021
Read More
Judge Advocates for Use of ChatGPT in Legal Interpretation
Judge Advocates for Use of ChatGPT in Legal Interpretation

Judge Kevin Newsom of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit embraced the use of ChatGPT in judicial decision-making, highlighting its potential benefits.

Jun 11, 2024
Read More
Big Law Gets Bigger, and So Do Expenses
Big Law Gets Bigger, and So Do Expenses

The 400 largest US firms show headcount growth again after two years of sluggishness, with an average growth rate of 2.2%, while operating expenses increased by 6.8%.

May 22, 2024
Read More
The Top Things to Remember When You’re Starting a New Job
The Top Things to Remember When You’re Starting a New Job

Hands have been shaken on your job offer (most likely by email) and arrangements have been set. Now it’s time for the job to begin. Perhaps you feel yourself transported back to the first day of elementary school as you put on your smartest work clothes and head off into the unknown. But whatever you’re feeling, there are a number of things you can do to set yourself up for success during your first few weeks at your new firm. Let’s consider this key initial period.

Jun 16, 2020
Read More
Twitter's Bold Leap to "X": A Legal Examination Amidst Branding and Strategy
Twitter's Bold Leap to "X": A Legal Examination Amidst Branding and Strategy

An analysis of Twitter's transition to 'X': The legal, branding, and financial implications of this bold move, and the challenges it presents in the contemporary social media landscape.

Jul 27, 2023
Read More
Ready to hire?

Schedule a free consultation to discuss your hiring needs.

Free 15-min consultation
Legal.io Platform
5 star reviews
Hiring made smarter

Easy-to-use platform for hiring legal talent, managing spend, and optimizing your panel — plus an average savings of 50%.

Need Immediate Help?

Submit a hiring request and let our experts handle the entire process for you.