Community Perspectives: Has anyone come into a company in a non-attorney position and transitioned to counsel?

In-house legal professionals share insight their experiences with internal growth.

(Author) Attorney

I have a non-attorney role but my company often assigns legal issues to navigate (contract review, dispute resolution, legislative/policy developments). I’ve been there 2.5 years and, when I came on, the role was pitched as one that would grow into counsel, then GC, within 5 years. I plan to leave but I want to change my title so my resume/LinkedIn look better for job applications. - Has anyone come in on a non-attorney role and grown to counsel? Has anyone pitched their way into a counsel title?

Counsel Responses:

Yes, I came in as “contracts specialist”. About 8 months in, I did a pitch with what I could be doing as counsel. The slide deck was complete with a new job description and responsibilities, I showed where they could cut out side costs etc. I had to wear both hats for about a year before they made me manager and hired another contracts person under me. It was definitely worth it for the title and growth potential.
Does your employer pay for your Bar membership, CLE expenses, etc? If so, it would appear like they are treating you like as a lawyer without compensating you like one. As for your direct question, I'd be careful referring to myself on a formal résumé as "counsel" if an HR reference-check would not support that characterization. I would, however, include some job description referencing that I "perform other functions typical of in-house counsel" and let your prospective employers infer from there.
I would definitely try to get the title, as it's critical that you have an attorney title for career growth. We have legal analysts doing most of our contract review and basic legal research work, but legal opinions are only rendered by an attorney. If they're treating you as an attorney, and paying for your licensing, it sounds like you have an attorney role, but they are deflating the title just to warrant paying you less. Aside from ethical issues, there may also be issues with maintaining attorney-client privilege (or lack thereof) since you are not the company's attorney. You might be able to use this the help persuade them to give you an attorney title, like counsel, or even associate counsel. Once you get it, jump ship.

Attorney and Associate Responses:

I started in-house after law school and came in without the counsel title, but I was doing a lot of counsel-type work just supervised by counsel. The only thing I didn’t do was provide legal opinions to the business. After two years they promoted me to counsel.

In-house? Join the conversation on Fishbowl (anonymous).

MIT Report Finds 95% of AI Pilots Fail to Deliver ROI, Exposing “GenAI Divide”

A July 2025 MIT study finds 95% of enterprise AI deployments fail to deliver value. Back-office automation and vendor partnerships emerge as key to success.

Technology

Aug 23, 2025

AI and Copyright: OpenAI Asks Court to Partially Dismiss Authors' Copyright Lawsuits

Recently filed cases raise the question, ‘Who is the owner of AI-generated content?’

Technology Copyright

Sep 05, 2023

eDiscovery Sector Growth Positivity Tempered by Associated Risks: Insights from Fall 2023 Survey

Complex Discovery's eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey results.

Technology In-House Counsel

Oct 05, 2023

Recruiters: 3 Things To Do Before Posting A Position

As a hiring manager, you know finding the right person for each position is an arduous task that involves a considerable amount of work even before you post the role. After pinning down the particulars of the role you and your company are looking to fill, the next step is finding the perfect match! Here are a few tasks/mindsets to understand and account for before posting the role.

Career

May 15, 2020

Legal Insights

Legal Industry Posts Strong Q1, but Thomson Reuters Warns of Rocky Quarters Ahead

Law firms saw positive gains in Q1 2025, but rising expenses and declining productivity may foreshadow a difficult stretch ahead, according to Thomson Reuters.

May 06, 2025

Community

Job Board

Salary Insights

Legal.io

Community Perspectives: Has anyone come into a company in a non-attorney position and transitioned to counsel?

Customer Stories

How Plaid used Legal.io for Flexible, Cost Effective Legal Talent

How Medallia Managed Legal Overflow and Accelerated Deals with Legal.io

How Verily Addressed High-Volume Commercial Counsel Needs with Legal.io

How Zoom Streamlined Legal Operations with Flexible Staffing

More from Legal.io

MIT Report Finds 95% of AI Pilots Fail to Deliver ROI, Exposing “GenAI Divide”

AI and Copyright: OpenAI Asks Court to Partially Dismiss Authors' Copyright Lawsuits

eDiscovery Sector Growth Positivity Tempered by Associated Risks: Insights from Fall 2023 Survey

Recruiters: 3 Things To Do Before Posting A Position

Legal Industry Posts Strong Q1, but Thomson Reuters Warns of Rocky Quarters Ahead

Ready to hire?

Hiring made smarter

Need Immediate Help?