Chicago Law Firm in Hot Water Over Biometric Privacy Concerns

A recent lawsuit filed against Mandell Menkes accuses the firm of violating Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA).

Chicago Law Firm in Hot Water Over Biometric Privacy Concerns

In a world where technology is advancing at an unprecedented rate, the ethical and legal implications of biometric data collection are becoming increasingly important. A recent lawsuit filed against a Chicago law firm, Mandell Menkes, brings these concerns to the forefront. The firm is accused of violating Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) by allegedly scanning and storing the fingerprints of a former legal secretary, Nancy Gagen.

Nancy Gagen, who worked at Mandell Menkes from 2006 to 2019, filed a complaint on August 18, 2023, in the Cook County Circuit Court. She alleges that the firm unlawfully collected, used, and stored her "personal biometric identifiers and biometric information" without her consent. According to Gagen, the firm installed a Fingertec Biometric device in 2015 and required her to scan her right index finger at the beginning and end of each workday, as well as during her lunch breaks.

The Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) was enacted in Illinois in 2008 to regulate the collection and storage of biometric data. The law mandates that companies must inform individuals why and for how long their biometric data will be stored. Gagen claims that Mandell Menkes failed to provide this information and never obtained her written consent for the data collection.

The lawsuit emphasizes that this is Gagen's "one and only chance" to seek compensation for the alleged violations. The complaint also warns about the potential future risks of losing control over personal biometric data, stating that the "full ramifications of biometric technology are not fully known."

Gagen is seeking statutory damages, and as of now, neither the counsel for Gagen nor Mandell Menkes have responded to requests for comment.

Customer Stories

See how leading enterprise in-house teams have scaled smarter with Legal.io's high-caliber flex talent.

More from Legal.io


Courts Grant TROs to Jenner & WilmerHale Against Trump Executive Orders

Federal judges granted TROs to Jenner & Block and WilmerHale, blocking parts of executive orders targeting the firms over their client relationships and pro bono work.

Mar 28, 2025
Read More
Legal.io Reaches 50,000 Members, Growing 6.5x in Two Years
Legal.io Reaches 50,000 Members, Growing 6.5x in Two Years

San Francisco, CA — Legal.io, the Silicon Valley-based hiring platform for flexible, in-house legal talent, is proud to announce that its membership has surpassed 50,000 legal professionals.

Jun 18, 2024
Read More
3 Tips for Law Firms and Remote Work

With stronger cloud tools, improved security, and wider connectivity - there isn't any reason why law firms cannot adopt sensible remote work policies. 

Mar 24, 2020
Read More
Ethical Considerations in the Age of AI: Adapting Legal Practices to Technological Innovation
Ethical Considerations in the Age of AI: Adapting Legal Practices to Technological Innovation

The legal industry confronts ethical challenges as it integrates generative AI technologies to enhance efficiency and automate workflows.

Nov 07, 2023
Read More
AI Adoption Outpaces Governance in Legal Departments

Legal teams are accelerating AI adoption but face growing governance and oversight challenges as risk, competency gaps, and policy frameworks struggle to keep pace with rapid deployment.

Feb 03, 2026
Read More
Ready to hire?

Schedule a free consultation to discuss your hiring needs.

Free 15-min consultation
Legal.io Platform
5 star reviews
Hiring made smarter

Easy-to-use platform for hiring legal talent, managing spend, and optimizing your panel — plus an average savings of 50%.

Need Immediate Help?

Submit a hiring request and let our experts handle the entire process for you.