Chicago Law Firm in Hot Water Over Biometric Privacy Concerns

A recent lawsuit filed against Mandell Menkes accuses the firm of violating Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA).

Chicago Law Firm in Hot Water Over Biometric Privacy Concerns

In a world where technology is advancing at an unprecedented rate, the ethical and legal implications of biometric data collection are becoming increasingly important. A recent lawsuit filed against a Chicago law firm, Mandell Menkes, brings these concerns to the forefront. The firm is accused of violating Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) by allegedly scanning and storing the fingerprints of a former legal secretary, Nancy Gagen.

Nancy Gagen, who worked at Mandell Menkes from 2006 to 2019, filed a complaint on August 18, 2023, in the Cook County Circuit Court. She alleges that the firm unlawfully collected, used, and stored her "personal biometric identifiers and biometric information" without her consent. According to Gagen, the firm installed a Fingertec Biometric device in 2015 and required her to scan her right index finger at the beginning and end of each workday, as well as during her lunch breaks.

The Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) was enacted in Illinois in 2008 to regulate the collection and storage of biometric data. The law mandates that companies must inform individuals why and for how long their biometric data will be stored. Gagen claims that Mandell Menkes failed to provide this information and never obtained her written consent for the data collection.

The lawsuit emphasizes that this is Gagen's "one and only chance" to seek compensation for the alleged violations. The complaint also warns about the potential future risks of losing control over personal biometric data, stating that the "full ramifications of biometric technology are not fully known."

Gagen is seeking statutory damages, and as of now, neither the counsel for Gagen nor Mandell Menkes have responded to requests for comment.

Customer Stories

See how leading enterprise in-house teams have scaled smarter with Legal.io's high-caliber flex talent.

More from Legal.io


How Happy Are U.S. Law School Alumni?
How Happy Are U.S. Law School Alumni?

Recent NALP Foundation study shows high employment and job mobility among Class of 2020 law grads. Debt and pandemic challenges impact career satisfaction and alumni engagement.

Nov 06, 2024
Read More
Disparities in Law Graduates' Earnings and Elite Lawyers' Salary Surge
Disparities in Law Graduates' Earnings and Elite Lawyers' Salary Surge

The Georgetown University CEW report highlights significant earnings disparities among law graduates, while top firms compete for elite legal talent in unprecedented salary increases.

Jul 05, 2024
Read More
Remote Work Revamp: ADA Concerns Surface as Companies Redefine Policies
Remote Work Revamp: ADA Concerns Surface as Companies Redefine Policies

Balancing needs, complying with law: Rethinking remote work in a world with disability rights.

Jan 31, 2024
Read More
4chan Rejects UK Online Safety Act Fines, Turns to Trump Administration for Support

4chan refuses to pay UK Online Safety Act fines, claiming extraterritorial overreach, and asks the Trump administration to push back against enforcement.

Aug 22, 2025
Read More
FTC Calls Out Consumer Protection and Competition Intersections in Copyright Office AI Proceeding
FTC Calls Out Consumer Protection and Competition Intersections in Copyright Office AI Proceeding

The FTC is emphasizing that AI must be developed and deployed responsibly, addressing consumer concerns in a recent comment to the Copyright Office.

Nov 15, 2023
Read More
Ready to hire?

Schedule a free consultation to discuss your hiring needs.

Free 15-min consultation
Legal.io Platform
5 star reviews
Hiring made smarter

Easy-to-use platform for hiring legal talent, managing spend, and optimizing your panel — plus an average savings of 50%.

Need Immediate Help?

Submit a hiring request and let our experts handle the entire process for you.