Community Perspectives: Would you take a Senior Counsel, Commercial role in a public company after being VP of Legal in a small private company?

In-house counsel weigh in on whether or not a step down on paper is a step back.

Community Perspectives: Would you take a Senior Counsel, Commercial role in a public company after being VP of Legal in a small private company?

Author (Legal Counsel)

Would you personally take a Senior Counsel, Commercial role in a public company after being VP of Legal in a small private company for the past 2.5 years (where there was no GC)? Recognizing most would be hunting for GC or at least AGC roles in a larger company.

I came across a Senior Counsel role that speaks to me in a well-respected public company with decent compensation and equity. I just don’t know if this perceived “step-down” would be a career ruiner/set me back considerably?

General Counsel Responses:

  • What’s more important to you: your title or money? For me personally, so long as I’m fairly compensated by the company you could call me Counsel for all I care. I’m paper chasing until I retire. My goal is to stack more and more money with each role to try and shave off as many years from retirement as I can. If your end goal is to retire a GC it might be a step back, so something you’d need to consider. I honestly don’t think companies will care especially if you explain in a cover letter that the job before this job was basically a GC/Head of Legal role. You need to decide what you want from your career. - Good luck!

  • Title works differently at different organizations. In really large legal departments, there are people who remain Senior Counsels for decades.

Counsel Responses:

  • At my F100 company we have Senior Counsel that were previously GC at small private companies. Honestly, focus on the compensation. Titles are meaningless.

  • At my mid-cap public company our deputy GC was GC at other places. Titles are kind of irrelevant. - Look at company size and pay.

  • Titles are meaningless - they all mean different things at different places. Will the new opportunity grow your skillset? Is the compensation in line with your experience and the market? Is there room for growth? If you like what the role has to offer, don’t get hung up on the title.

  • Pay is important, but also make sure the work is actually exciting to you and, if you're ambitious, upward potential is there.

Associate and Attorney Responses:

  • In-house titles are all over the place. If you like the role and you’re good with the pay, I say take it. I know at least one F500 that calls their most junior attorneys VPs. I don’t think the title means as much as the role/scope.

  • I personally would see this as a path to specialization, not a step down. You will likely take yourself off of the "moving toward GC" path, if you take this role. That may be your intention. - If not, understand growth trajectory/opportunities for advancement at the new role.

Give us your response and be a part of the discussion.

Customer Stories

See how leading enterprise in-house teams have scaled smarter with Legal.io's high-caliber flex talent.

More from Legal.io


Legal.io Surpasses 150,000 Members, Now Includes 1 in 7 U.S.-Based In-House Lawyers
Legal.io Surpasses 150,000 Members, Now Includes 1 in 7 U.S.-Based In-House Lawyers

The milestone makes Legal.io one of the largest in-house legal communities in the world, with growth accelerating across every measure: members, enterprise customers, and global reach.

May 21, 2026
Read More
ABA Urges DOJ to Reverse Ban on Judicial Nominee Vetting

The ABA called the DOJ's block on its judicial nominee vetting ‘deeply disturbing,’ defending its neutrality and urging Attorney General Bondi to reverse a 72-year precedent break.

Jun 10, 2025
Read More
Lawyers Leaving US Government Accelerate Workforce Shift

An exodus of federal government lawyers in 2025 is reshaping the U.S. legal labor market and boosting private sector hiring as agency ranks shrink and DOJ sees heavy losses.

Feb 03, 2026
Read More
Net Neutrality on the Brink: Court Decision Plunges Internet Freedom into Uncertainty
Net Neutrality on the Brink: Court Decision Plunges Internet Freedom into Uncertainty

A U.S. appeals court has temporarily halted the FCC's reinstatement of net neutrality rules until August 5, 2024, following a challenge from ISPs and trade groups.

Jul 15, 2024
Read More
Harris Beach and Murtha Cullina Merge to Create Northeast Powerhouse

Midsize firms Harris Beach and Murtha Cullina are combining to create a 250-lawyer firm spanning from D.C. to Massachusetts after both client bases grew and demanded more scale. The merger comes amid a broader wave of high-profile mergers launching this month.

Jan 03, 2025
Read More
Ready to hire?

Schedule a free consultation to discuss your hiring needs.

Free 15-min consultation
Legal.io Platform
5 star reviews
Hiring made smarter

Easy-to-use platform for hiring legal talent, managing spend, and optimizing your panel — plus an average savings of 50%.

Need Immediate Help?

Submit a hiring request and let our experts handle the entire process for you.