Customer Service is Your Law Firm's Competitive Advantage

A case study on Zappos and how to set your firm out from the competition.

Customer Service is Your Law Firm's Competitive Advantage

United States companies lose $62 billion in revenue every year from terrible customer service.

Surprised? We weren’t.

After all, creating a truly delightful customer experience is hard. Really hard.

This is even more true in law.

Clients come to us with their their legal issues, sure. But they're also coming to us with their motivations, aspirations, insecurities, and fears.

A 2016 article in The Lawyerist highlights this with some intense statistics:

  • Fewer than 10% of clients who call a law firm will actually get to speak to a lawyer.
  • More than 40% of people who leave a voicemail or fill out a web form wait two or three days before they hear back.
  • 11% of callers hang up within 10 seconds of calling a law firm because they’re frustrated at not getting to speak with the person they ask for by name.

Now is the time for firms to nail customer service. The firms that don’t will continue to fall further behind.

Today clients not only want, but expect, exception service. They interact with brands like Apple, Amazon, Zappos, and UPS - they know what quality feels like, and they want it from everyone.

Firms that prioritize client service will be able to differentiate themselves.

Zappos

Consider the case of Zappos.

Zappos, founded in 1999, is now the World's largest online shoe retailer.

The company didn't gain traction because they provided a superior online shoe shopping experience. After all - plenty of online marketplaces tried (and failed) to capture this vertical.

Zappos' growth hack was their customer service.

Tony Hsieh, CEO of Zappos, describes this differentiator perfectly. Zappos is a “service company that happens to sell shoes.”

In order to make this vision a reality, Zappos invested heavily in their customer support team and processes. A 2012 Business Insider article reported that new Zappos customer success representatives receive seven weeks of training and are encouraged not to use scripts.

This strategy worked for Zappos, and almost 20 years later it is still working. In July 2009 it was acquired by Amazon for $1.2 billion.

Law Firms + Client Success

Zappos may have billions in the bank, but it was their values that drove their differentiation - and thus their success. This is something every firm can learn from.

Here are some of the top tips and tricks for providing superior client success:

Communication is key. Be clear about the best way for clients to contact you and set a standard response time with them (ex: you’ll respond within 24-hours during the week).

Create a Roadmap. Clients often have anxiety over what is left to be done on their matter and what forward-looking expectations they should have. Outlining the process from the start can ensure a more seamless relationship.

Invest in your staff + make good hires. Zappos customer success representatives go through 7 weeks of training. Additionally, at the end of training each employee is offered around $4,000 to quit. Yes, you read that right. This ensure that they’re hiring people who are truly committed to the role.

Customer Stories

See how leading enterprise in-house teams have scaled smarter with Legal.io's high-caliber flex talent.

More from Legal.io


AI Adoption in Legal Sector Soars, Study Finds

A survey by Clio finds that AI adoption in the legal sector has soared from 19% to 79% in just one year.

Oct 10, 2024
Read More
Harvey AI Hits $5B Valuation Amid Legal Tech Expansion

Harvey AI secures $300M Series E funding, doubling valuation to $5B, and outlines expansion into adjacent professional services beyond legal.

Jun 24, 2025
Read More
Community Perspectives: Do your years of experience "reset" when you go in-house?
Community Perspectives: Do your years of experience "reset" when you go in-house?

In-house legal professionals discuss how they perceive years of experience in a law firm vs. in-house, and how they correlate to each other.

Oct 27, 2022
Read More
AI Terms Legal Professionals Should Know: A Practical Glossary
AI Terms Legal Professionals Should Know: A Practical Glossary

This glossary explains core AI terms in plain English, with context and examples geared towards attorneys and other legal professionals.

May 28, 2026
Read More
Kirkland & Ellis’ Dominance Challenged as Rival Firms Adopt Aggressive Partner Investment Model
Kirkland & Ellis’ Dominance Challenged as Rival Firms Adopt Aggressive Partner Investment Model

Rival Firms Embrace Aggressive Partner Investment Models, Challenging Kirkland & Ellis' Dominance

Dec 12, 2023
Read More
Ready to hire?

Schedule a free consultation to discuss your hiring needs.

Free 15-min consultation
Legal.io Platform
5 star reviews
Hiring made smarter

Easy-to-use platform for hiring legal talent, managing spend, and optimizing your panel — plus an average savings of 50%.

Need Immediate Help?

Submit a hiring request and let our experts handle the entire process for you.